Seven Stories Press

Works of Radical Imagination

The America Syndrome

Apocalypse, War, and Our Call to Greatness

by Betsy Hartmann

America_syndrome-f_feature

In this thought-provoking, big-idea book, Betsy Hartmann sheds light on a pervasive but—until now—invisible theme shaping the American mindset: apocalyptic thinking, or the belief that the end of the world is nigh. Tracing our nation's fixation with doomsday from the Puritans to the present, Hartmann makes a compelling case that apocalyptic fears are deeply intertwined with the American ethos, to our detriment. Hartmann shows how apocalyptic thinking has historically contributed to some of our nation's biggest problems, such as inequality, permanent war, and the exploitation of natural resources. While it is tempting to view these problems as harbingers of the end times, this mindset constricts the collective imagination and precludes social change. The truth is that we have much more control over the future of our planet than we think, and our fatalism is much more dangerous than the apocalypse. In The America Syndrome, Hartmann seeks to reclaim human agency and, in so doing, revise the national narrative. By changing the way we think, we just might change the world.

America_syndrome-f_feature

Buying options

“Betsy Hartmann calmly eviscerates the prophets of apocalypse whether it be Malthusian doomsayers obsessed about brown-skinned immigrants with high birth rates or climate-change fearmongers . . . Hartmann’s book is a timely debunking of anti-intellectualism in American life and of all those demagogues who have stoked American nativist paranoia. The America Syndrome explains the Age of Trump in the deepest cultural sense.”

“The 'America First' stance espoused by Donald Trump appears as little more than a pastiche of crowd-pleasing campaign tropes, but in fact draws on themes long embedded in American political thought. To guide us through this rich and momentous history, stretching from the Pilgrims' landing in Plymouth to the onset of climate change, there is no better account than Betsy Hartmann's The America Syndrome.”

“Betsy Hartmann has written a compelling tragedy of the American psyche that is a fitting riposte to Trumpery. It's a tragedy about a country that lacks self-awareness, that thinks itself special when it is 'not so special after all.' Militarists and apocalyptic environmentalists alike are caught up in this quagmire of exceptionalism, this tragedy of failed imperialism. Cut the hubris, America; it is your undoing.”

blog — July 11

Betsy Hartmann on How Progressives can Resist Apocalyptic Thinking


From Wier Harman's Town Hall Seattle Interview with The America Syndrome author Betsy Hartmann:

Originally posted at Town Hall Seattle

Have you ever had a “Last Question” you wish you’d had a chance to pose at a program? Town Hall Executive Director Wier Harman recently had that experience when he moderated a question and answer session with Betsy Hartmann, author of The America Syndrome. So he dropped her a line the next day and asked the following:

Elizabeth Warren recently said "The progressive agenda is America’s agenda. It’s not like we’re trying to sell stuff that people don’t want—it’s that we haven’t… been as clear about our values as we should be or as clear and concrete about how we’re going to get there.” Considering your diagnosis of an America Syndrome—a national propensity for apocalyptic, fatalistic thinking that “constricts the collective imagination and precludes social change”—is the problem for progressives one of explaining the vision, or of forming it coherently in the first place?

Betsy Hartmann responded:

“Progressives face both these problems, and they are inter-related. In order to articulate a compelling vision that can win widespread political support, a coherent program needs to be developed.  What exactly do we want and how do we get there? Take health care, for example. The idea of a single payer system is gaining traction, and the more progressives can speak clearly and concretely about what the transition from Obamacare (assuming it survives the Republican attack) to single payer would entail, the more convincing the argument. In a sense we need to take the wind out of the sails of fake news and rhetorical hyperbole by charting a practical course toward social democratic/democratic socialist policies on health, education, immigration, environment, economy, labor, social justice and foreign policy. For sure, the challenges are immense, but the message should be that we are capable of problem-solving.

Apocalyptic, fatalistic thinking is not helpful in this process. Reading climate change as the end of the world, for instance, can sink people into despair, when there needs to be informed political debate and action on what kinds of climate policies are most effective in speedily reducing carbon emissions, adapting infrastructure, and protecting the most vulnerable communities.  The America Syndrome also tends to lock us into a U.S.-centric vision when successful climate policies in other countries have a lot to teach us.

The bright side of apocalyptic thinking—that history unfolds along providential lines, leading toward a golden millennium—is problematic, too, encouraging false expectations of perfection. In his inaugural address, Trump proclaimed, “We stand at the birth of a new millennium,” but it’s not just the right wing that makes such claims. Parts of the left also appeal to a kind of moral purist, utopian brand of identity politics that often gets in the way of crossing bridges and building real political solidarities.

The Trump era demands a sort of progressive multi-tasking. While fighting against his retrograde policies, we simultaneously need to develop a multi-issue political program that is inspirational precisely because people understand that it is achievable.”

We’re told to “be the change we want to see”—but what if we can’t see it? Tracing our nation’s fixation with doomsday from the Puritans to the present, author and Hampshire College professor Betsy Hartmann argues that fatalism and apocalyptic thinking is a curse on the American mindset that restricts our capacity to imagine social change. Her latest work, The America Syndrome: Apocalypse, War and Our Call to Greatness, presents an optimistic perspective that feels custom made for many of us in the current cultural moment: we have more control over the future than we think. Instead of imagining our doom, Hartmann helps us envision a better tomorrow.

 

Hartmann_betsy-f_feature
Betsy Hartmann writes nonfiction and fiction about important national and global challenges. She is a well-known educator, commentator, and advocate on women’s rights, population, environment, and security concerns. Her new book The America Syndrome: Apocalypse, War and Our Call to Greatness explores how end-times thinking profoundly influences American foreign policy, environmental politics, and the persistence of injustice. Now in its third edition, Betsy’s feminist classic Reproductive Rights and Wrongs: The Global Politics of Population Control tackles the powerful myth of overpopulation and its negative consequences for women’s reproductive health and rights. She is also the co-author of A Quiet Violence: View from a Bangladesh Village and co-editor of the anthology Making Threats: Biofears and Environmental Anxieties. Her political thrillers The Truth About Fire and Deadly Election explore the threat the Far Right poses to American democracy. 

Betsy is professor emerita of Development Studies and senior policy analyst of the Population and Development Program at Hampshire College in Amherst, MA. She received her BA magna cum laude in South Asian Studies from Yale University and her PhD in Development Studies from the London School of Economics. To learn more about Betsy, visit http://betsyhartmann.com/.